Our Domestic Life
Hundreds of geese flocked in Maria’s yard every day, because she fed them, and because, as she would tell you, all animals are born seeking things, food being perhaps the most fundamental one. Shelter is another, she would often say, motioning at her two plywood doghouses which were full, by then, of geese. The dogs were long gone. Years ago they would run and bark in the yard and scare some of the geese away, but those days were over. Now it was a trouble to visit her, stepping around the geese, and the droppings of the geese, and the croutons scattered in the wet grass. When Kitty made it up to the house she found Maria dead.
It must have happened just that day. The croutons were reasonably fresh and so was Maria, sitting in her wingback armchair in front of the bay window. Kitty opened the door and two geese followed her inside, but there were already ten or twelve of them in the house, as usual. Sometimes Kitty wondered if they were always the same ones, or if Maria switched them out, which would be more fair. They padded around the kitchen floor with their beaks close to the ground, looking for more food. But there was none. Maria was done feeding them.
“Oh Maria,” Kitty said. She stopped by the edge of the counter, looked from across the room. She could tell Maria was dead by the color of her skin, a gray-blue that spread over her, starting from her lips. Kitty wondered about a heart attack, or some kind of suffocation. She decided it was impolite to ask so soon.
“It’s all right,” answered Maria’s voice. Her mouth didn’t move, no part of her did, but Kitty could hear the dismissive wave of her hand. She knew better than to press the matter. She picked the bag of croutons up off the counter and pulled it open.
“Don’t do that,” said Maria. Kitty looked at her. The geese were already converging at her swollen sandaled feet, sniffing up at her like the dogs used to do. “They have to learn to get along for themselves now.” Kitty made a skeptical face, but Maria only tutted. “They’ll leave eventually, when they realize there’s no more food.”
Kitty wasn’t sure about that. The geese had probably been born there, and even if they left they would probably return, from what she knew about geese. But after a second, she zipped the bag and put it down.
“Can I at least open the window?”
She felt Maria’s shrug, the roll of her eyes.
“If you must do something.”
Kitty went over to the bay window, nudging the geese out of the way, passing close to Maria, who didn’t turn to look. Her eyes were open, fuzzed over, fixed toward the door. Her hair, which was a wig but a good one, was as shiny as ever. Kitty opened the window and the wind came in and tousled it around, which almost made Maria look alive again.
“Does anyone know?” Kitty said. Maria scoffed. “I’ll have to get someone. I’ll have to call the police, probably. I can’t get you out of here myself.”
“No one is getting me out of here.”
Kitty moved in front of her, looked her dead in the face. Whenever Kitty saw her own mother, it seemed like she’d aged years, but somehow Maria always looked the same. Maybe it was because when Kitty first laid eyes on her, she was already as old as Kitty thought anyone could be. Kitty had been fifteen and wandering the streets, surrounded by a group of boys, like she often was back then. It was before she’d met Dan. They were all throwing rocks at the geese. Maria had stormed out of the house and the boys had scattered, but Kitty had stayed there. She’d stared right back. Now she sat down on the ottoman and the goose perched on it hissed.
“I’ll have to get Dan, at least.”
Maria clicked her tongue, or the spirit of her tongue.
“How is Dan?”
“Good,” said Kitty. “He got promoted. Or he’s going to. Third shift manager.”
“Third shift?”
Kitty shrugged. “He wanted it. He wanted more hours.”
Maria’s hair blew a little into her face. It recalled the judgmental way she would tilt her head.
“Because of the baby?”
Kitty tilted her head too, sullen. Then she rolled her eyes away.
“You’re going to have to stop it,” said Maria.
“I’m not talking about it,” said Kitty.
“We’ll talk about whatever I like.”
“Because you’re dead now? You’ll be gone by the time it’s due.”
“And what will you do then?”
Kitty shrugged again. She looked at her nails.
“You always act like it’s a bad thing.”
“It’s a hysterical pregnancy,” said Maria.
“It’s not hysterical,” said Kitty. She had dropped out of high school six years earlier, but she read enough to know what that meant. “I’m doing it on purpose. For Dan.”
There was a pause during which the living Maria would have made her eyes knifelike, looked Kitty up and down. The dead Maria did nothing.
“Then you’re a liar,” her voice chided. “That’s even worse.”
Kitty scowled and pulled up her t-shirt. It showed her popped bellybutton, the rounding tightness of her skin.
“It’s not a lie,” she said. Maria tutted and the geese echoed her. But when she spoke again her voice was softer than usual.
“What will you do,” she said again, “when the time comes and there’s no baby?”
Kitty put her shirt back down. She slouched around her belly.
“Maybe I’ll make one,” she said.
“Can you do that?”
“I don’t know. I never tried.”
Maria seemed not to know what to say. She had never tried either, or at least never succeeded. One of the geese padded up to sniff at Kitty and she pushed it away in the baseless irritation she felt all the time these days. The goose moved on to Maria and looked closely at her hand, a loose claw on the arm of the wingback chair. It touched it with its beak and Maria did nothing. The goose came no closer, but it didn’t go away.
“I can’t just leave you here, you know,” Kitty said. “I’m pretty sure it’s against the law.”
“To die in my own home?” Maria balked. Kitty knew that would rile her, Maria hated the law. But now that she’d said it, she didn’t know why she’d bothered.
“I don’t know.” Kitty looked at her hands, the geese. “Isn’t somebody going to want the house?”
Maria said nothing. Kitty didn’t think she would. She rested her hands on her stomach like she saw pregnant women do. Maria rested hers on the arms of her chair and neither of them felt anything.
It was three days before Kitty made it back to Maria’s, what with work and all, and her slowness from the pregnancy, and anyway she knew Maria wouldn’t be happy to see her. The sky was gray and cool. There were no fewer geese in the yard. They mumbled in a sound that seemed to move like the clouds did, rippling over the house. Kitty arrived at the door and found that it was wide open.
“Did you do this?” she said, motioning at it. The house, of course, was overrun. There were geese on the countertops, nestled in the empty sink, tucked into the built-in shelves like dolls among Maria’s things. They were all over Maria, on her chair, in her lap. They had pulled up her sleeves, pushed aside her skirt. Under them, her arms and legs and stomach were gorily disturbed.
“Maria,” Kitty said urgently.
There was no answer right away. The goose-muttering put her on edge. Maybe she was too late, maybe Maria was already gone. But then the air moved in a scornful exhale and the worry turned to embarrassment, then annoyance. Kitty narrowed her eyes.
“If you can open the door you could at least feed the geese.”
Maria knew why Kitty said that, Kitty knew she did.
“They don’t need it,” Maria’s voice said. Kitty knew why. There was one of them on Maria’s lap with its head up her blouse. In some other light it could have been a baby nursing.
The smell wasn’t bad, considering. The door and the window were wide open, and Maria had smelled good all her life, perhaps that carried over. Perhaps the geese were eating away all the rotted parts. Maria said they would eat almost anything.
“Well, I’m taking you out of here,” Kitty said. “I’ll get the police to come right now.”
“No.”
“Dan, then. He can come in the work truck.” She still didn’t know what would happen after that. Certainly Maria wouldn’t go quietly. Kitty passed the sealed crouton bag, abandoned on the counter, and dropped heavily onto the ottoman. She pushed two geese to the floor, and they hissed and snapped at her, their black bills shining. “Have you thought about where you want to go?”
This was the customary way to ask, as far as Kitty knew. But Maria hated all customs and Kitty knew she’d like this one no better.
“Have you?” her voice shot back. Kitty glared at her body. But then she shrugged, considering.
“Dan says he wants to be buried,” she said. “But he wants to be loose in the ground. No coffin. So the dirt decomposes him.”
“Dirt doesn’t decompose things,” Maria said. “It’s bacteria and fungus. And animals.”
This time the change in Maria had been swift, like the days had been years, lifetimes. The wig had slid mercifully down her forehead, but under it her face was as soft as the rest of her and just as picked apart. Kitty looked at her hard still, the fierce gaze they had always shared. It was the same one, Kitty realized, the geese had now on Maria. A look like they could gnaw her through with their black pebble eyes.
“Well, that’s what he wants,” Kitty said.
“That’s not what I asked,” said Maria. Kitty scoffed and kicked one of the geese, whose bill was creeping up her shorts. She had cupped her hands over her belly again, a habit she was forming. Sometimes she felt movement in there, bubbles and contractions. But she peed on the stick every once in a while, and each time it came back clean.
“I’m sure we could get you a spot at the church,” Kitty said. Maria scoffed and didn’t answer. “Or there’s that place out on South Street. They’ve got a mausoleum.”
Maria still said nothing. In life she sometimes feigned deafness, sometimes so well Kitty couldn’t tell if it had finally come true.
“Where are the dogs buried?” Kitty asked. There was a pause, then a disparaging huff.
“I cremated them.”
“Is that what you want?” Kitty looked around. “Are they in an urn somewhere?”
“I put them out on the grass. Ash is good fertilizer. I wanted them to be of some use.”
Kitty looked out there, through the open door, at the grass that was as goose-covered now as it surely was back then. She wondered who exactly the dogs had fertilized.
“Is that what you want?” she repeated. She turned back to Maria. She tried not to see the new goose approaching, pecking toward a winnowed calf.
“I want you to leave us alone.”
Kitty found herself pressing her lips together, but she thought better of crying. Maria was not one for sympathy. Kitty wasn’t either, or she didn’t used to be.
“You won’t last long either way,” she said, “with all this.”
The room creaked, a shrugging shoulder.
“They don’t live as long as we do,” said Maria. “To them it could seem like years.”
Kitty made a point not to look at the geese, how they had spread onto the furniture, colonized the shelves, bloomed around like big dark flowers growing from the floor. She had a fleeting impulse to reach out and grab Maria, the thin claw of her hand that the geese had not yet touched. It was a wave like greed, like hunger, roots creeping toward loose bones. Then for some reason it all made her sick.
“And then what?” she snapped. “They’ll all still be here with no food, no one to feed them.”
“They’ll leave,” said Maria, “when they’re done with me.”
“And go where? This is their home. You’re like their mother.”
Maria scoffed.
“They’ll leave. And so will you.”
“I can’t leave you here like this.”
“Of course you can.”
“I can’t. I’m the only one who knows. I feel responsible.”
“You’re not responsible for me,” Maria said. “You can stop pretending.”
“What?”
“Just because you’ve gotten sentimental now, this fantasy with Dan–”
“Fantasy?” said Kitty. “What is that supposed to mean?”
But she knew what it meant. She tightened her grip on her belly. Something strained against her, but of course it was just her nerves.
“I’m going to get him,” she said. She stood up from the ottoman. The feeding geese looked up to glare at her, or maybe it was Maria glaring through them.
“If you bring Dan here, I’ll tell him the truth.”
“No you won’t,” Kitty said. But death changed people. Maybe she didn’t know what Maria would do anymore. Kitty stared at her, her slumping form, eroding like old land. She had asked her once where she was born, where her family was, and Maria said that “family” was a grotesque human farce. Snakes, for example, live mostly solitary lives.
Geese raise their young, Kitty had quipped, and they mate for life. Maria had smiled spitefully. She said, only the good ones.
“Dan is a good man,” said Kitty. One of the feeding geese blinked at her.
“And what are you?”
Kitty didn’t answer. She didn’t know how. A murmur rose up, a heckling foreboding, from the geese, or from Maria, Kitty couldn’t tell. Perhaps it came from all of them. Perhaps now they were one and the same.
Kitty waited a week, because of work, the pregnancy, she didn’t quite know why. Maria said animals do things out of instinct, that they know what’s good for them, or at least what they are destined for. Dan drove them in the work truck. They let him use it personally. When Kitty met him, he didn’t have a car, but she did, an old white Volkswagen Golf she’d bought herself at nineteen. She drove Dan around back then, but things were different now, because of the pregnancy, because of destiny. They still had the Golf but hardly drove it anywhere, and nobody knew it was hers. When they parked outside Maria’s house Dan got out and opened her door.
“You weren’t kidding,” he said about the geese, who still covered the yard, snuffling in the wet grass for worms, or something. Kitty watched their fervor and grimaced, something twisting in her guts. She stopped on the doorstep, and the inside seemed the same as the outside, full of goose droppings, gray feathers, wet gray air.
Dan waited for her. He was a gentleman like that. Eventually Kitty stepped across the threshold and the geese hardly moved. In spite of the weather she was still in her sandals. She felt their warmth on her feet.
“Maria?”
It was stupid to ask. Kitty didn’t see Maria right away, but she knew where she was. The wingback chair was empty except for a lump of cloth on the seat. The wig must have fallen to the ground.
Kitty stepped forward and Dan moved in behind her. She felt him there, his head above her head, felt him gasp a little as he took in what was before them. Maria was hard to see amid the geese, scattered like she was on the Persian rug, the wood floor. In the light her clean bones hardly even looked white. They were the same gray as the birds.
“I brought Dan,” said Kitty’s voice. It didn’t quite seem like hers, as if, like Maria’s, it came down from some other place. “He said he’d help.” Although there wasn’t much to help with anymore.
“Hi Maria,” said Dan. That gentle voice. Kitty steeled herself for him to say something tasteless, but he never did that. The fear she had was something else. She swallowed it and walked across the room.
The geese parted for her disdainfully, as usual, bickering as they lurched out of the way. The others bobbed up and down, making room, refusing to. Under some of them she saw flashes of vertebrae.
“We’re going to take you to the church,” Kitty said. She sat on the ottoman so lightly it hardly felt like sitting, like the pressure in her belly was floating upward, lifting her. She looked at the lump, the blouse on the chair, the dark stains all around. “They said they’ll do the last rites, and then they’ll take you to be cremated. And we’ll spread your ashes, like you did with the dogs. We can do it here. Or anywhere you want.”
Kitty waited for Maria’s answer, for her sigh. Half of her expected it, and the other half didn’t. The geese were still muttering, voices within voices. But if Maria’s was among them Kitty couldn’t hear it. Maybe it left with the flesh.
“He’s here,” Kitty whispered softly, barely more than a breath. Just loud enough for Maria, for the form under the blouse. “I had no choice. So tell him if you want. I don’t care.”
The wind blew, maybe a breath from somewhere. No voice except the geese.
“He’ll leave me, you know. I’ll have nothing.” Kitty glared at the fabric, the brown watercolor spots soaked and dried into the white. “That’s what you want, isn’t it?”
Maria didn’t answer. The force in Kitty’s stomach lunged. She reached forward and snatched the blouse away, tossed it to the ground.
She’d expected a skull, a face to fight with, but that must have fallen to the floor with the wig. Dan appeared behind her, after a moment. When he saw what it was he put his hand on her shoulder.
“Oh,” he breathed, the way he did, the way their home would when he left. Maria’s ribs were picked clean, wet like the grass, shining. A single goose had crawled inside the cage. It was a small one, young, or maybe very old. With its feet tucked in and its neck wrapped on its wing, it fit there perfectly.
There was a long quiet, the geese, the wind.
“That’s nice,” Dan whispered. “It’s almost like…”
Kitty turned and found him looking at her, down below her eyes. He didn’t need to say it out loud. They were both thinking it, all three of them, all the dozens and dozens of them filling up the house, the yard. After a second Dan sat down next to Kitty. He moved a goose so gently it didn’t even hiss.
“Maria,” he said softly, tilting his soft head. He rested his hand on Kitty’s stomach, like something that wasn’t hers. “We had something we wanted to say. We were thinking, if it’s a girl…”
He hesitated. He looked at Kitty. Kitty looked at the goose. Its shoulder against the sternum, its cheek in a delicate curve. Then its black eye opened and saw her looking. Its body shuddered, almost snakelike, shifted inside the ribs.
“Do you want to tell her?” Dan asked.
Kitty’s mouth opened a long time before her voice came.
“I don’t know if she’s here anymore.”
Dan pressed his hand down, like to comfort her. Could he feel what was inside there, curling, quivering?
“She might be able to hear still,” he said. “You never know.”
Kitty drew her breath, the same breath as the geese, the same breath that used to be Maria’s. Maybe it still was. Maybe if Kitty riled her enough, which she knew this would. Maybe there was nowhere from which Maria couldn’t spite her.
“We were thinking,” she said, “if it’s…a girl. We were talking about naming her Maria.”
She waited for the snort, the laugh behind closed teeth, the harsh voice, dulled in the walls, but still clear enough to ruin her. Enough to tell the truth, to get Dan’s hand off her stomach, to empty her ribs of the thing that was in there, growing as it ate.
But no voice came, at least not that one. The wind blew in from the door. It ran along the floor, slipping through the geese, misting up around them and carrying their sound. Wings rustling, necks stretching, feet smacking on the floor. It swept over Kitty and laid her hair across her face, and when she turned to free it, there was Dan. He was looking at her and his eyes were like theirs, seeking. Something more than food or shelter. Or perhaps just that.
Kitty stood up. She wrapped her arms over her belly. She stepped away from Dan toward Maria, toward the goose. It was still curled up in there, long dark head to the wing. But its eye looked at Kitty. Its mouth moved with the rest. Maybe Maria was speaking through them one last time, bossing, chiding, knowing everything. Maybe they were just trying to say her name. Ma ma ma ma ma.